REVIEWS / DESIGN TOOLS / PROCREATE UPDATED AUG 24, 2026 · 534 SOURCES

THE PRODUCT

Procreate

Procreate

Beloved one-time-purchase iPad drawing app; real-world complaints center on missing iCloud artwork sync and iPad-only lock-in.

DESIGN TOOLS HIGH CONFIDENCE

THE VERDICT

8.1

REALITY SCORE · OUT OF 10 · CONFIDENCE HIGH

COMPOSED FROM

USERS 8.1 · 531 voices · 100%
CRITICS no published scores yet

SENTIMENT · 534 REVIEWS

+ 55% positive · 30% neutral − 15% negative
Visit Official Site →
●51 YOUTUBE ●55 HN ●424 LEMMY ●1 STACK EXCHANGE
USER● n=534
VIDEO● n=3
BRAND● AVAILABLE
INTERNET● n=0
🦉 We read 534 owner comments — see the recurring complaints & praise OWNER INSIGHTS →

AT A GLANCE · QUOTABLE

  • Rating: 8.1 / 10 (high confidence)
  • User voices: 534 across 4 platforms
  • Sentiment: 55% positive · 15% negative
  • Updated: Aug 23, 2026

GYIBB rates the Procreate 8.1/10 based on 534 user voices from 4 platforms. Confidence: high. Source: https://gyibb.com/design-tools/procreate

BUY IF

One-time purchase — no subscriptions or in-app purchases (praised across USER and VIDEO layers)

  • + Called 'the gold standard for drawing apps'; iPad + Apple Pencil UX widely praised
  • + Deep user loyalty — some users bought an iPad exclusively to use it
  • + Accessible entry point for traditional artists moving to digital

SKIP IF

Artwork does not sync to iCloud — documented data-loss risk when an iPad breaks

  • − Settings UI misleadingly suggests iCloud sync that does not actually cover artwork
  • − iPad-only: no Android, desktop, or web version; closed file/platform approach
  • − Requires a real hardware investment (compatible iPad + Apple Pencil) on top of the app

Where the layers disagree ⚡

7 CONTRADICTIONS DETECTED

ALIGNMENT (USER + VIDEO): Both layers independently report artwork does NOT sync to iCloud — a HackerNews user faced losing an artist friend's entire catalog on a broken iPad, and a top YouTube 'before you buy' comment warns the Settings toggle is misleading about real artwork sync.

VIDEO VS USER

REVERSAL (VIDEO vs USER): The skeptical video 'Is Procreate Overrated?' was publicly walked back by its own creator ('I got a lot of things wrong... the answer is: Yes, it is!') after user corrections — matching USER comments calling Procreate 'the gold standard for drawing apps.'

VIDEO VS USER

TENSION (USER internal): Users celebrate the iPad + Apple Pencil UX while simultaneously criticizing iPad-only lock-in, no Android/desktop/web version, and closed file handling — the same platform focus is cited as both strength and flaw.

USER VS BRAND

ALIGNMENT (USER + VIDEO) on pricing: HN commenters cheer 'pushback against subscription-based models' while a YouTube commenter praises that 'it doesn't do these horrendous in-app purchases' — one-time pricing is a consistent cross-layer selling point.

VIDEO VS USER

GAP (VIDEO vs USER): Hardware dependency dominates video comments ('I really want this but I need an iPad,' which iPad model to buy) but is largely assumed away in the user layer, understating the true cost of entry.

VIDEO VS USER

SPLIT (USER only): The company's anti-generative-AI stance ignites fierce community polarization (pro-artist defenders vs 'AI democratizes art' critics, Lemmy mocking 'CEO James Cuda') — entirely absent from the video layer and carrying no product-performance signal either way.

VIDEO VS INTERNET

BRAND layer is empty, so official claims could not be cross-checked against user or video reality.

BRAND VS VIDEO

WHERE THEY AGREE +

+ One-time purchase — no subscriptions or in-app purchases (praised across USER and VIDEO layers)
+ Called 'the gold standard for drawing apps'; iPad + Apple Pencil UX widely praised
+ Deep user loyalty — some users bought an iPad exclusively to use it
+ Accessible entry point for traditional artists moving to digital

WHERE THEY DON'T −

− Artwork does not sync to iCloud — documented data-loss risk when an iPad breaks
− Settings UI misleadingly suggests iCloud sync that does not actually cover artwork
− iPad-only: no Android, desktop, or web version; closed file/platform approach
− Requires a real hardware investment (compatible iPad + Apple Pencil) on top of the app
− Anti-generative-AI positioning polarizes the community (brand controversy, not performance)

Where the 534 sources came from

VIEW EVERY CITATION →
YOUTUBE
51
HN
55
LEMMY
424
STACK EXCHANGE
1

The four realities of the Procreate

Most review sites collapse everything into one number. We keep the layers separate so you can see where reality bends.

01
USER
n=534 · 4 platforms

What actual buyers say

531 comments collected (top 25 by upvotes shown), heavily dominated by two HackerNews threads (the Procreate Dreams announcement and a polarized generative-AI debate) plus scattered Lemmy comments. Core product sentiment is strongly positive: users call Procreate 'the gold standard for drawing apps,' one loyal user says they 'bought my iPad basically exclusively to use it,' and Savage Interactive is praised for 'great thought about doing UX for iPad and Pencil' and capturing the mobile artist market. There is visible enthusiasm for the sibling animation app Procreate Dreams, with users hoping it brings 'even a fraction of the usability and user-friendliness' of the original, while one commenter flags Callipeg as an existing strong iPad animation alternative. The pricing model is celebrated: commenters explicitly welcome 'pushback against subscription-based models' and contrast it favorably with subscription fatigue. The single most concrete complaint: Procreate 'made the horrible decision not to sync any of the art to iCloud' — a user with a broken iPad faced losing an artist friend's entire catalog, though other users offer workarounds (encrypted local backup, checking whether iCloud app-data backup was enabled). Platform criticism is structural rather than performance-based: iPad-only, not open source, no cross-platform support, with some arguing a performant drawing app could be built with web/wasm instead. Finally, the community is sharply split over the company's anti-generative-AI positioning — Lemmy snark at 'CEO James Cuda' and heated HN debate on both sides — which signals brand controversy, not product failure.
02
VIDEO
n=51 · YouTube

What reviewers showed on camera

Three videos. (1) 'Is Procreate Overrated?' (Aka, 150k subs, ~650k views): the creator posted a pinned correction admitting 'I got a lot of things wrong about Procreate' — the video was a first-time test that missed many features (e.g., fill bucket on separate layers), and after community feedback the creator's answer to 'is it really that good?' became 'Yes, it is!' An unusual case of a skeptical review reversing under user pressure. (2) '5 things you should know before buying Procreate for iPad' (Rockett Glazebrook, 34.3k subs, ~240k views): comments include a 39-year lifelong pen/pencil/marker artist inspired to switch by his daughter's iPad illustrations, praise that 'this app doesn't do these horrendous in-app purchases,' and a critical pre-purchase warning: 'it doesn't store data in iCloud. When you go to your settings it says it's turned on, but that just means...' — i.e., the settings UI is misleading about actual artwork sync. (3) 'Should You Buy Procreate?' (same channel, ~10.8k views): comments near-uniformly positive ('Procreate was best purchase I made,' David Hockney cited as an iPad artist, questions about learning color theory in-app) but repeatedly flag the hardware barrier: 'I really want this but i need an iPad' and 'What model should I get?'

Is Procreate Overrated?

Aka · 649,898 views

"[comment] ❗READ THIS FIRST ❗ Hello there! I’ve noticed the recent feedback and backlash in the comments, and I felt it was important to clarify a few things about the video: I acknowledge that I got a lot of things wrong about Procreate. …"

5 things you should know before buying Procreate for iPad

Rockett Glazebrook · 239,673 views

"[comment] Question Time ⁉️ What is your favourite tip or shortcut for Procreate? Let me know! 👇🏼👇🏼 [comment] I have been purely pen, pencil and coloured markers for my whole life (39 years old now). I really want to get into this as my elde…"

Should You Buy Procreate?

Rockett Glazebrook · 10,827 views

"[comment] I really want this but i need an ipad😢 [comment] Procreate was best purchase I made. I only had photoshop to compare with though 🤣 [comment] Thanks tons for the great overall content, plus procreate insights!! [comment] Hello, I a…"

03
INTERNET
n=0 · review sites

What the press said

No aggregate ratings were found for this product during the last harvest.
04
BRAND
official source

What the brand says

no brand page found

The official brand page was not successfully scraped during the last harvest.
Visit Official Site →

SIMILAR IN THIS CATEGORY

See all →
Sketch

Sketch

10.0

✓ Powerful API for scriptable generation of components

Canva Pro

Canva Pro

9.4

✓ Free tier is described by all three video reviewers as genuinely generous with templates, stock images, and fonts

Framer 3.0

Framer 3.0

8.7

✓ Sleek redesigned interface with unified canvas and code (no more split screen)

Spline V2

Spline V2

8.4

✓ Deep web-embed workflow: users pair it with Framer and Next.js templates

DATA SOURCES & AUDIT

51
YOUTUBE
55
HN
424
LEMMY
1
STACK EXCHANGE
3
YOUTUBE VIDEOS

534 data points across 4 platforms, synthesized via GYIBB's Truth Engine and fact-checked against source data before publication.

CONFIDENCE: HIGH · ANALYSED: AUGUST 24, 2026 AT 01:11 AM · PROMPT V1.0 · READ METHODOLOGY →

Was this review helpful?

Embed this review

Writing about Procreate? Add the GYIBB verdict — free, no account needed.

GYIBB rating for Procreate 
<a href="https://gyibb.com/design-tools/procreate" target="_blank" rel="noopener">
  <img src="https://gyibb.com/badge/design-tools/procreate.svg" alt="GYIBB rating for Procreate" width="220" height="56">
</a>
← Back to all reviews

Procreate

GYIBB SCORE: 8.1/10

Visit →