High comfort and traction, but durability and waterproofing face serious user skepticism.
⚠️ Limited data: 16 comments, 10 videos. Consider as preliminary assessment.
Cross-Layer Tensions
- ▸ BRAND claims 'durability', but USER comments report soles falling apart at 65-75 miles and VIDEO reviews show soles wearing down 'like crazy' prematurely.
- ▸ VIDEO creators praise GTX waterproofing as 'amazing', but USER comments report waterproofing failing at 4-6 months consistently.
- ▸ VIDEO reviews hype the shoe as a revolutionary flagship, but a competing VIDEO (Ridge & River) admits the X Ultra 5 had to 'fix everything wrong' with this specific model.
- ▸ BRAND implies general high performance, but USER comments explicitly warn those with wide feet or those doing heavy inclines to avoid this model entirely.
Other Sites' Ratings
Not enough data collected yet for this product
Pros
- Exceptional comfort out of the box
- Excellent stability and traction on trails
- Lightweight, nimble trail runner feel
- Great for narrow feet
- Quicklace system is convenient (when it stays tight)
Cons
- Waterproofing fails prematurely according to long-term users
- Sole durability is highly questionable (chunks falling off)
- Laces come loose frequently (every 2-3 miles)
- Not suitable for wide feet or heavy incline hiking
- Insoles flatten quickly over time
Four-Layered Reality Analysis
User Reality (16 Reddit + 0 Trustpilot)
Based on 16 Reddit comments, the USER REALITY is heavily mixed and polarized. On the positive side, users widely praise the immediate comfort (likened to trail runners), grip, and narrow European fit (highly recommended for narrow feet). One user completed giant chunks of the PCT in Salomon trail shoes. However, there are massive red flags regarding longevity and specific features. Multiple users report the soles losing chunks or falling apart between 65-75 miles, while another went through 3 pairs quickly on inclines. The GORE-TEX waterproofing is heavily criticized; one user reported it failed at 6 months, and again at 4 months on the replacement pair, while another explicitly warned that 'they ain't waterproof' if water goes over the top. The lacing system is also a pain point, working loose every 2-3 miles. Fit is highly polarizing: if you have wide feet, users strongly advise looking elsewhere due to the tight toe box, suggesting Merrell Moab instead.
Video Reality (10 YouTube videos)
Based on 10 YouTube video transcripts, the VIDEO REALITY is largely positive but admits structural flaws. Several creators (Dusty Hikers, Bem Kicks) call it the 'best hiking shoe' with phenomenal stability, protection, and traction. However, deeper long-term testing reveals issues. Short Reviews With Seth (500 miles tested) heavily criticized the shoe: the waterproofing fails easily ('they ain't waterproof'), the sole wore down prematurely, the support lacked, and the Ortholite insole flattened completely. Another channel (Ridge & River) notes that the newer X Ultra 5 specifically 'fixed everything wrong about the X Ultra 4', implicitly confirming durability and chassis issues in this model. Creators agree it functions like a nimble trail runner rather than a heavy-duty traditional boot, performing best on paths rather than concrete.
Featured Video Reviews:
New Salomon QUEST 4 GTX Or Salomon X ULTRA 4 MID GTX - Which Is Better?? (2021 Updates)
What they say: "hi there guys this is trevor from armed outdoors and if you're on this video then you are interested in which one of these boots either the x ultra from solomon the new x ultra 4 or the quest for is the better boot stay tuned [Music] al…"
Salomon X Ultra 4 GTX Review (NEW Salomon Hiking Shoes Review)
What they say: "welcome to firearms of america today as you guys can see i have another pair of salomon boots or shoes for review but this is a very very special review not just any kind of salomon this is the brand new finally the brand new x ultra 4 gtx …"
What they say: "Alan here with Dusty hikers today I'm going to talk to you about a shoe that everyone is just raving about lots of people that review hiking shoes have found this to be like the best hiking shoe recently that's come out from any man…"
Salomon X Ultra 04 GTX Mid Hiking Shoe - Short Reviews with Seth
What they say: "today we're talking about the solomon x ultra iv gtx mid this is a hiking boot shoe uh kind of something in the middle offered by solomon i've had them for nine weeks and worn them about 500 miles on all manner of surfaces everythin…"
Salomon X Ultra 5 Fixed Everything Wrong About the X Ultra 4
What they say: "today we're talking about a battle of two iconic shoes we've got the X Ultra 4 here which is the previous rendition of the X Ultra mid hiking shoe that Solomon has perfected over the years versus the new upgraded X Ultra 5 so same s…"
Salomon X Ultra 4 Mid Review After 1 Year | Still Worth It ?
What they say: "Hey everybody, Tyler with Mountaineer Journey. We are going to review the Solomon X Ultra 4 mids. So, let's get into our review of the Solomon X Ultra 4 mids. So, previously we had reviewed the low cut version of this hiking boot. And I…"
DON'T Buy Hiking Shoes Until You Watch This (2026 Review) - Merrell Moab vs. Salomon X Ultra
What they say: "So, this is going to be a comparison between uh two of very popular hiking shoes, the Merrill Moab and the Salomon X Ultra. Now, if you're looking for great videos and amazing visuals and all, you won't find it in this video. This i…"
What they say: "the most important tool of a nature traveler and hiker is his shoot this important tool can affect performance and prevent injuries especially in dangerous sports such as hiking today I want to introduce you the best hiking shoes in the wor…"
REVIEW (2026): Salomon X Ultra 4 GTX Shoes. Features
What they say: "The Salomon X Ultra 4 GTX shoes stand out for combining the nimble feel of a trail runner with the support needed for demanding hikes. Their Gortex membrane keeps feet dry through steady rain and shallow stream crossings while still allowin…"
Internet Reality (no aggregate ratings found)
No aggregate ratings were found for this product during the last harvest.
Brand Reality Official Site ↗
The brand reality makes minimal, generic claims, promising 'superior cushioning, breathability and durability, to upgrade the comfort and performance of your shoe.'
- NewFeaturedNew ArrivalsBest SellersLaunch CalendarCollectionsAlpen Blossom PackEnergy PackRed Ashes PackViolet PackRecon PackOrchid PackIconsXT-6SpeedcrossX UltraXA ProXT-WhisperXT-4
- New Arrivals
- Best Sellers
- Launch Calendar
- Alpen Blossom Pack
- Energy Pack
- "superior cushioning, breathability and durability, to upgrade the comfort and performance of your shoe."
Data Sources
Confidence Level: LOW
Analysis Date: April 24, 2026 at 08:26 PM
Prompt Version: 1.0