REVIEWS / VACATION RENTALS / OWNER INSIGHTS
🦉 WE READ 179 OWNER COMMENTS
Vrbo: what owners actually say
Owners and guests alike call out Vrbo for poor communication, vanishing reviews, and outdated listings — though the platform still offers unique properties hotels can't match.
What owners complain about
- Reviews disappear or get suppressed SOME
Multiple users report that accepted reviews vanished later, and one user founded a competing site (Dwellable) specifically after being unable to post a negative review about a bad vacation rental experience on VRBO
- Hosts don't respond or update listings SOME
One user contacted ~30 Vrbo properties for a ski trip; only 13 called back (under 50%), many over 9 days, and several had already sold the cabin but hadn't bothered to update their listing availability
- Non-transaction-based review system SOME
Unlike Airbnb's transaction-verified reviews, Vrbo allows reviews from people who never completed a stay, making ratings less trustworthy according to users comparing platforms
- Platform feels outdated and clunky FEW
Users report that basic features like viewing availability in search results were introduced as a 'new feature alert,' suggesting the platform lagged behind competitors in functionality
- Listings plagued by scams and bait-and-switch pricing SOME
Users report advertised prices jumping at checkout (e.g., $150/night becoming $230/night), and NYC listings specifically called out as 'pure scam'; excessive cleaning fees also cited
What owners love
- Unique properties you can't get elsewhere
Vacation rentals offer whole homes, lake houses, and cabins in locations where hotels aren't available, which is the core value proposition that keeps users coming back
- Some hosts are genuinely excellent
-
Experienced travelers note massive variance in quality but say hosts who care about their property and guests stand out, and reading reviews carefully helps identify them
- Hosts have flexibility to make things right
When issues arise, individual hosts can respond and compensate more creatively than chain hotels with rigid policies, according to users who've had good resolution experiences
Surprising patterns
- Owners report constant petty damage and theft (things going missing, breaking, not being reported by guests) as a routine cost of doing business, which may explain why some hosts seem defensive or charge high cleaning fees
- Guests complain about problems that are actually cultural norms (e.g., renting sheets and towels in France, walk-up apartments on fifth floors) rather than actual host failures
- The review ecosystem across ALL platforms is considered fundamentally untrustworthy by savvy users — fake reviews, suppressed negative feedback, and conflict of interest (platforms earn revenue from hosts, not guests) are widely assumed
WHO SHOULD SKIP IT
Travelers who need reliable, responsive booking confirmation and trustworthy reviews should skip Vrbo — the platform's non-verified review system and low host response rates make it risky for time-sensitive trips.
Synthesised from 179 real owner comments across 4 platforms. Every point is grounded in the comments — no marketing, no AI guessing. How we do it →