REVIEWS / GENERAL / OWNER INSIGHTS
🦉 WE READ 112 OWNER COMMENTS
SHIUI: what owners actually say
Commenters admire the procedural landscape generation but keep tripping over a broken HTTPS certificate on the demo link and architectural quirks like 4,000 lines of code in a single file
What owners complain about
- HTTPS certificate warning on demo site SOME
Multiple commenters report Firefox security warnings when opening the demo at lingdong-.github.io — the certificate is not valid for that subdomain — and the issue appears tied to a Cloudflare/DNS/GitHub Pages edge-case bug, forcing use of an alternate link
- All code lives in a single index.html SOME
At least three commenters find it 'strange' that the entire ~4,000-line JavaScript project sits in one index.html rather than split into mountains.js, trees.js etc.; defenders counter it keeps the project self-contained and manageable in any editor
- Object placement can be unrealistic FEW
One commenter observed tiny trees placed in the water near shorelines and on top of rock formations, placements 'I have yet to have seen in the real world' — though another replied that trees rooting in cracks and splitting boulders is actually common in nature
- Bugs and performance problems in the original code FEW
One commenter who rewrote the code in C reports finding clear mistakes where 'it is clear what the author intended, but it is not what he wrote' (e.g. fences rendering incorrectly until fixed) and replaced O(n^4) algorithms for better performance
- Over-engineered or unconventional code style FEW
The author himself acknowledges the `times` solution was overthought and was later dropped in favour of `range`-based rewrites, part of a broader pattern of unconventional for-loop rewriting that divides commenters
What owners love
- Impressive procedural generation quality
Commenters call it 'incredible' and a 'great project', with one noting the math largely deals with rotation and scaling, with a dedicated function for every object variation, each setting its own colour — suggesting individual object colours can be tweaked to see what renders
- SVG output is a standout feature
One commenter specifically praised the SVG aspect of the project as what makes it 'great', since the generated landscapes are vector-based
- Author's broader portfolio is worth exploring
Multiple commenters highlighted that the creator's personal site (lingdong.works) hosts many other interesting projects, with one thanking another commenter because they 'might not have discovered his other works page' otherwise
- Creative inspiration for other developers
One commenter used it to inspire a full code-rewrite blog series and rewrote it in C, calling the original 'an inspiring series of writing'; others riff on extending it with hidden 'Where's Waldo'-style objects to generate searchable game content
Surprising patterns
- A geologist commented that all real landscapes are themselves procedurally generated — just with a slower generation process than the software — an unexpected cross-disciplinary endorsement of the underlying concept
- The project sparked existential commentary about automation, with one commenter predicting 'the robots are coming for the visual artists and illustrators, fast' and setting a 2020-to-2030 timeline for the shift
- Interest in the software drove traffic to an adjacent discovery: nostalgic memories of the picture book 'Tiki Tiki Tembo', which one commenter revisited — alongside its debated status as cultural appropriation — after seeing the artwork style
WHO SHOULD SKIP IT
Per the comments, buyers who expect a polished, production-ready tool with clean modular code, working HTTPS links and realistic object placement should skip this, as it is best appreciated as an impressive but quirky single-file art experiment.
Synthesised from 112 real owner comments across 3 platforms. Every point is grounded in the comments — no marketing, no AI guessing. How we do it →