REVIEWS / GAMING CONSOLES / OWNER INSIGHTS

🦉 WE READ 593 OWNER COMMENTS

New PS5: what owners actually say

Owners enjoy the PS5's performance and ease of use, but a significant backlash erupted over Sony's internet requirements for single-player games and fears about long-term game preservation.

LEMMY · 486 YOUTUBE · 60 HACKERNEWS · 44 STACKEXCHANGE · 3

What owners complain about

  • Internet required for single-player games COMMON

    Owners report needing an internet connection (even phone hotspot) to launch single-player titles like GTA V. Users with no home internet for months were locked out of games they owned physically.

  • Console may be useless in the future COMMON

    Multiple owners worry that in 10-25 years, when servers go down, the PS5 and its games will be unplayable—unlike older consoles (Genesis, PS1, Dreamcast) that still work as long as you have the hardware and media.

  • Sony's anti-consumer track record SOME

    Commenters dredge up Sony's past behavior (the CD rootkit scandal, always-online requirements) and note the irony that Sony mocked Microsoft's Xbox One always-online stance before adopting similar practices.

  • Day-one patches undermine physical media SOME

    Physical media collectors point out that even disc owners are affected, since games often require day-one patches to function properly, making the disc alone insufficient.

  • Save data locked to accounts FEW

    Users report that save data is bound to the PSN account that created it and cannot be transferred to a different account, even on the same console.

What owners love

  • Great gaming experience with 4K performance

    Owners playing titles like Ragnarok, Spider-Man 2, and Battlefield report being very happy with the graphical fidelity and 4K capability.

  • Ease of use for PC gamers

    Long-time PC gamers who switched say the PS5's plug-and-play simplicity is underrated and a welcome change from PC gaming.

  • SSD upgradeability is worthwhile

    One owner swapped in a 2TB Samsung T500 SSD and reports a truly noticeable improvement in real-world use, cautioning that compressed YouTube videos don't do the difference justice.

  • PS Portal pairing is excellent

    An owner pairing the base PS5 with the PlayStation Portal remote play device calls it one of the best gaming experiences they've ever had.

  • Long-term reliability

    Multiple owners with launch or base PS5 units report the console still going strong into 2026 with no issues.

Surprising patterns

  • Long-time PC gamers are genuinely impressed by the PS5's ease of use, not just its performance—suggesting the console wins on convenience, not just power.
  • The PlayStation Portal accessory is singled out as transformative by at least one owner, pairing with the PS5 to create a standout experience that marketing barely mentions.
  • Owners draw a direct line between piracy and game preservation—multiple commenters state bluntly that only pirated copies of games will remain fully playable decades from now, reflecting deep distrust of digital ownership models.

WHO SHOULD SKIP IT

Anyone without reliable internet access—deployed military personnel, people in areas with poor connectivity, or those who want to play their purchased single-player games offline—should avoid the PS5 based on owner reports.

3.6/10 GYIBB verdict
Full review →

Synthesised from 593 real owner comments across 4 platforms. Every point is grounded in the comments — no marketing, no AI guessing. How we do it →