REVIEWS / GAMING CONSOLES / OWNER INSIGHTS

🦉 WE READ 236 OWNER COMMENTS

Edition PS5: what owners actually say

Owners appreciate the PS5's digital edition pricing but repeatedly flag the disc-free limitation as a critical constraint for physical game owners.

LEMMY · 132 YOUTUBE · 59 HACKERNEWS · 15 PRODUCTHUNT · 15 REDDIT · 11 STACKEXCHANGE · 4

What owners complain about

  • No disc drive on Digital Edition COMMON

    The digital edition is disc-free, meaning owners cannot use physical game discs at all — you must repurchase games digitally if you previously owned them on disc

  • Cross-gen upgrade value questionable SOME

    Some owners question why they'd upgrade when PS4 'Warmastered Edition' versions already run at 4K/60FPS, making the PS5 version's improvements unclear

  • Deluxe/Collector edition bonuses feel insultingly thin SOME

    Owners mock deluxe edition bonuses like '2 skill points' as being the worst possible addition, feeling nickel-and-dimed

  • Parental controls block age-rated content for child accounts FEW

    A parent discovered their 12-year-old couldn't play PEGI 16 titles like Horizon Forbidden West on the child's own account due to parental controls, requiring workaround redemption on parent's account

What owners love

  • Backward compatibility with PS4

    Owners note PS4 versions of games remain available and playable, with some already achieving strong performance like 4K/60FPS on existing PS4 editions

  • Digital edition priced fairly relative to hardware

    Some owners acknowledge the digital edition's pricing as reasonable when considering the hardware capabilities offered

  • Game library flexibility across PlayStation platforms

    Owners appreciate that PS4 versions of games are still accessible and often reasonably priced alongside PS5 upgrade paths

Surprising patterns

  • The DRM-free and physical ownership conversation is still very alive — owners openly discuss piracy as a preference when companies restrict access or remove purchasing options
  • Linux/Steam Deck users actively work around platform limitations using tools like Heroic to access their GoG libraries, suggesting PlayStation's closed ecosystem is a real frustration for cross-platform gamers

WHO SHOULD SKIP IT

Buyers with large physical PS4 game collections should skip the Digital Edition, since they cannot use any existing disc-based games without repurchasing them digitally.

GYIBB verdict
Full review →

Synthesised from 236 real owner comments across 6 platforms. Every point is grounded in the comments — no marketing, no AI guessing. How we do it →